Home Site Map
Writings Home Page
 

Time to blow the whistle

Irregularities and exploitation of students and faculty are common in Doon's private colleges. Is anybody listening?

Dr Nitin Pandey

28-Dec-2011

“They promise the moon, charge the earth but give us only peanuts” is how Ritika Jain, a 2nd year Engineering student describes her college. As private colleges and universities mushroom in Doon, tales of exploitation of students and faculty abound, shared in hushed tones. Everyone is afraid, students of “being backed” (failed) and faculty of losing their jobs. This report is an attempt to force all of us to acknowledge, what we all know, but are reluctant to accept. While the author has not personally verified these stories, the number of stories going around is enough to merit a discussion. For security reasons, pseudonyms are used.

“Colleges lure students with attractive websites and brochures, promising the best faculty in the country, a good learning environment and 100% placements. The truth is that they advertise and accept admissions for courses which have not been approved and then force students to choose another stream. It is difficult to remember the names of our faculty as they change more rapidly than the seasons; we’ve had four deans in 3 years” recalls Ritika.

If one was to discount exorbitant tuition fees, the “other” charges are as killing. “We are charged Rs 20,000/- per semester for books” says 24 year Arvind, a final year B.Tech student. “And we have never got books worth more than 3000/- Rs and the books we get are of no use to us. Who do we complain to? If we complain to the administration we are threatened with ‘backs’. Once we join these colleges, we become like bonded labor and because our future is at stake, with our parents spending so much money, we keep quiet” he continues.

Complaints abound of tampering with results & attendances, favoritism and nepotism. “Few students, work full time somewhere and have not even attended a dozen classes during the whole year, yet they are never debarred from exams for lack of attendance and they manage to secure pretty good marks too” says another student. Refusal to show answer sheets after the exams leads to suspicion of manipulation of marks. Chosen few, invariably relatives of big wigs are always sent as college representatives for inter college events and national level academic meets, with other students having no clue at all. Labs without basic equipment and libraries without books are a common complaint.

“The rudest shock comes when you are in the final year” says Parag, a third year law student. College authorities, reportedly, wash their hands off placements and refuse to even invite companies to the campus. “Most of the vacancies are filled up by college placements and since our college is not inviting them, we are helpless, as walk-in jobs are rare to find.”

The faculty is equally exploited. Working from the top floor of a school building, an Engineering College is reputed to be employing under-qualified and underpaid staff. “Even though I resigned over a year ago, my name is still in the faculty list and I’m shown as being on Maternity leave” says Meena. “During UGC inspections, another lady was presented as me. The staff were instructed to say that their salaries are Rs 30,000/- per month, when it is a third of that” she reveals. “On being asked why the College functions from one single floor, their standard reply over the last three years is that their own building has cracked and is being repaired. Either the inspection teams are too dumb or choose to ignore such blatant lies” she says.

Suparna, teacher in a well-known University, recalls how she was given a posting order to Imphal with a weeks’ notice “I had to resign. There is no way I could pack my bags, leave my family and reach Imphal in one week. After working for so many years in the college, I deserve more respect than this” she rues.

Stories of irregularities & exploitation are endless. Even if one were not to believe any, one has to admit that there is no complaint redressal mechanism in private colleges which gives their administrators an air of autocracy. It is time the State administration sets up an independent body to safeguard the interests of the students and faculty of the private colleges, where the complainant is assured of a fair hearing and secrecy, without their careers being jeopardized.



Get Updates Get SMS Updates
Add to Google Receive SMS Updates
Top

Please comment on the article



Your Name:
Your E mail:
Comments:

Abusive, inappropriate or offensive comments are likely to be edited or deleted.


Read comments

Date30-Dec-15
From: I only would many thanks from the start. I not ralley know some tips i may possibly exhausted the lack of whole referrals brought according to your self on this kind touch. It actually was an unnaturally discouraging challenge with me, however when you co
I only would many thanks from the start. I not ralley know some tips i may possibly exhausted the lack of whole referrals brought according to your self on this kind touch. It actually was an unnaturally discouraging challenge with me, however when you consider a good professional alternative the public restricted because helped me you can rebound on celebrate. I'm surely simply just more joyrful used for the help support unsurprisingly good luck we imagine you uncover what a tremendous line of business you could be coming into training courses extra individuals who the use of a website. Most likely you have never notice any person.


Date14-Oct-15
From: If it can teach you important slklis that you can walk away with then it may be worth a shot, but I think I would hire someone who came from a standard Uni before an online one.
If it can teach you important slklis that you can walk away with then it may be worth a shot, but I think I would hire someone who came from a standard Uni before an online one.


Date06-Jan-12
From: Dushyant Pande
dear Sir, read ur article, needless to say very well written.. while reading this i felt as if you have written evrything what we being students in dehradun feel about our colleges.. leaving other things apart, i have personally observed how nicely people sitting in the admission cell attends you whereas there is no one in the examination cell to attend the person coming. the thing which i hate most is, when we are given admissions so nicely then why we are not treated in the same manner throughout our student life?




Top